The Mafia Discussion Thread

[Ruki]

I think when one of these mafias start to die down I'll start work on my next.

RR2? MARIO Mafia? Something else? Who knows?

[TheRossWalker]

I'm now almost done with roles for Futuramafia, and if I don't get enough signups for Haiku Mafia, I'll axe it and run Futuramafia instead.

Once things die down a little, of course.

[Josh]

I'm now almost done with roles for Futuramafia, and if I don't get enough signups for Haiku Mafia, I'll axe it and run Futuramafia instead.

Once things die down a little, of course.

Change the name, but otherwise do that.

[Ruki]

What Josh said.

So, when is You Pick 3?

[Josh]

Given the utter abortion that was You Pick 2, I would have to re-attempt that first. Also, I'd have to know that there's actual interest from several people at least.

I figured YP2 left a bad taste in a lot of people's mouths.

[Josh]

And good lord, for once I didn't pick up on the point Ruki was making. God, I'm slipping.

[Ruki]

....I was making a point? I was actually just curious as to when you'd run the next YP.

[Evafreak]

Has anyone ever done Aliens Mafia? Been watching my box set again and seems like it could be a good one

[C-MIL]

I need one more for the Five-Timers Club.

[TEOL]

I need one more for the Five-Timers Club.

I prefer the name 'Mafia Whores'.

[C-MIL]

Even better.

[Josh]

....I was making a point? I was actually just curious as to when you'd run the next YP.

Shoulda known.

So yeah, I'll only run that again if there's a lot of interest. Last one went horribly, no?

[-A-]

Do another Drinking Game mafia, that was awesome (even though I died immediately.)

Edited September 18, 2008 by -A-

[Josh]

That one was pretty work-heavy for me. Though it could be fun, given the right circumstances.

[Ruki]

I'll admit, that YP2 ended kinda horribly (can't remember why), but I would still be very interested.

...also, what point do you think I was trying to make?

[C-MIL]

You still owe us House Mafia.

[Josh]

I had just agreed with TEOL that traditional mafia games long-ago gave way to gimmicky ones, then you asked about my most gimmicky game ever.

And it ended horribly because of inactivity and a convoluted storyline. I shoulda ditched the storyline. Inactivity I couldn't help.

[-A-]

That one was pretty work-heavy for me. Though it could be fun, given the right circumstances.

Yeah, I can imagine with the tolerance levels and all that it would be tough ... maybe a smaller number of people and a more limited number of roles. Though I'd suggest that for any game

[Josh]

House Mafia, got it. So, I'm running three simultaneous games soon, right? Wait, make that four with 12 Angry Men.

[Josh]

That one was pretty work-heavy for me. Though it could be fun, given the right circumstances.

Yeah, I can imagine with the tolerance levels and all that it would be tough ... maybe a smaller number of people and a more limited number of roles. Though I'd suggest that for any game

And the tolerance levels themselves need adjusting too, as a few people pointed out when the game ended. Too many people were getting drunk too easy and too often. Too.