The Mafia Discussion Thread

[Mr Evil Guy]

Survivors Mafia it is (Y).

I'd rather that than take the name oldskool thought of, well, unless he wanted to co-run it. I'll start up signups now.

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

I'd like to nominate the last couple days of SSB Mafia as "worst town performance ever". Anyone disagree?

[GoGo Yubari]

You have no idea how glad I am that my complete idiocy in CHIKARA Mafia has been completely outshined. No idea.

[Blaze09]

Note to self for TNA Mafia: Do NOT put MEG, Sousa, and GoGo together as mafia

Edited August 3, 2008 by justblaze09

[D-Day]

Or just make sure I stayed alive. Had DMN gave the Gooey Bomb to someone else and I stayed alive to the end, town would have won. I guarantee it.

[Mr Evil Guy]

Or just make sure I stayed alive. Had DMN gave the Gooey Bomb to someone else and I stayed alive to the end, town would have won. I guarantee it.

Uh, no. You wouldn't have.

No offense, but if Essa and Ace couldn't figure it out you couldn't either.

[D-Day]

Oh, boo. That's not for certain, only extremely likely.

[Ruki]

So, what did everything think of Smash? Are there any unanswered questions? And should I run a new mafia? Y/N/BIH?

Of course, it wouldn't be until after Survival/Civil War/Blazing Saddles.

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

Either Mafia group was composed of better players than the top three/four townies. Not a good idea.

[Josh]

I haven't looked at the recap carefully, but if what MPH says is true, then yes, that's something to correct. Yes, roles should be assigned randomly . . . at first. But once that's done, you gotta examine how things have shaken out and try to keep the odds as even as possible, preferably with as few changes as possible.

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

Sousa/GoGo/MEG were one Mafia. Another had me and Pesci.

The town had Josh, Plubby until he was converted, and then...DMN?

[GoGo Yubari]

And Norro and Hugar, both of whom were posing the biggest threats in terms of competent daytime play, both turned out to be individual.

[Josh]

Fuuuuuuck, that town was DOOMED.

[Blaze09]

Im surprised what I can do while the board is down at home, I already have the roles and the abilities done for TNA mafia (YAY ME!) but I still want to wait for these three mafias are done then I might go ahead with it. But Ruki, you screwed the town from the get go when you put GoGo/Sousa/MEG on the same mafia, that was just unfair.

EDIT: TOO MANY M's

Edited August 4, 2008 by justblaze09

[Mr Evil Guy]

As if you confused me for MPH.

You always fuck up our names, justblaze.

[thuganomic]

Damn Hugar keeping calling me stupid in Traditional Mafia.

[Plubby]

My only complaint is the one already voiced, Ruki: That when the town's best three hopes are comprised of myself and Ace, the town is in deep poop.

And that I continue to get no post-game credit.

[oldskool]

I refuse to consider Ace a "best hope" for anything, since there's an above-average chance he gets modkilled for MSNing about the game in every mafia he joins.

[Plubby]

He was allowed to MSN in SSB - me and ace are mentioned in each other's PM's.

[FireDoughnut]

Where did TEOL go?