The Mafia Discussion Thread

[D-Day]

I've only been in four.

Three died before night 2 and the fourth one isn't going so good for me so far

2 so far, both killed on Day 2. First time, killed by a bomb (SSB Mafia) and second time crippled with a broken neck. Although I'm getting a bit further in Traditional Mafia, god bless lack of abilities.

[NobBe Nobbs]

I've won at least twice. Once was Mafia II (HEY GUYS DID YOU KNOW I WON MAFIA II? AS A SERIAL KILLER?!) and the second was the second Web Comic Mafia, as Kiyoshi Masamune. I can't remember whether I survived WCMIII (though I don't think so) and I have a feeling I've won another time as well.

[Sousa]

I can't win. You fuckers keep killing me on the first night.

[Plubby]

3 - Be (Mafia II, Web Comic Mafia II, Heroes Mafia)

[Kaney]

I won in Mafia Cubed as the ridiculously overpowered Trad Mafia, and I won in the best mafia ever, MGS Mafia as Vamp of Dead Cell.

[Plubby]

I have never won .

This is because I am never scum...

And i'm always nightkilled because i'm so gosh-darn good.

That's my story and i'm sticking to it!

[Pleatherface]

Food Mafia (Gogo should be the only winner of that one, he handed the cult the game more than any other player with the exception of Essa.), A-Team (did nothing but use my one protection on Mr. T), Action Movie (Did what I could), WCW 2k (won the game mostly due to player disinterest, Essa's hand made roleclaim, luck, and Meg giving up.)

4 isn't bad when you're possibly the worst 'experienced' player on the board.

Came close in WCW II, Jobber II, and WCIII, but didn't quite get there.

[Plubby]

3 - Pleatherface (Action/Sci-Fi Mafia, A-Team Mafia, WCWMAFIA 2000)

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

5 wins for me. Firesale Mafia (I was individual but was traded to the Wings near the end), RTTGC (don't remember, but I think I was Mafia), Judgment Day Mafia (didn't do a whole lot), WWE Mafia (...heh), Domed (of course).

[Pleatherface]

Officially Shared Victory with Ace on Food, so it's more like 3 and 1/2 due to me leaving after I'd already converted Be and Gogo, but I'll take the 3.

[thuganomic]

You-Pick Mafia. I won by myself. I also won as the mafia in Nintendo Mafia. I'm probably forgetting something else.

[NobBe Nobbs]

I won in Mafia Cubed as the ridiculously overpowered Trad Mafia, and I won in the best mafia ever, MGS Mafia as Vamp of Dead Cell.

HOW THE FUCK DID YOU WIN THAT?!

I still cannot believe you managed that.

[Pesci]

I only did it based on who survived at the end. Figuring out who won through other stipulations didn't matter to me really.

thug, you won Heroes Mafia too.

[Mr Evil Guy]

Man MGS mafia was sick. We(Benji, Kaney? and I) convinced the town that our secondary mafia was on their side.

I did a lot of the work, then being nightkilled the night before we won. :@:@:@

Also, Pescis mafia group in Traditional Mafia 2 or 1 killed me the night before the town won after I figured that shit out. I keep getting dicked over half the time. That always happens to me.

[Mr Evil Guy]

Also Pesci, you should compile some sort of standings. That'd be sick.

[Pesci]

I don't really wanna post the list here because it's a big list. Shall I make a topic and update it regularly?

[Mr Evil Guy]

Yes!

[Kaney]

Man MGS mafia was sick. We(Benji, Kaney? and I) convinced the town that our secondary mafia was on their side.

I did a lot of the work, then being nightkilled the night before we won. :@:@:@

Also, Pescis mafia group in Traditional Mafia 2 or 1 killed me the night before the town won after I figured that shit out. I keep getting dicked over half the time. That always happens to me.

What was so amazing about it was that I was stabbing people left right and centre, and OPENLY, and still no one lynched me. Benji and I ruled that shit. Be's reactions in the thread still make me guffaw.

[Pesci]

I made a new topic. Go see how big your dick is.

[Mr Evil Guy]

Reading through those standings make me wonder where the fuck titocoolace went.