The Mafia Discussion Thread

[Gongsun Zan]

I would push for a mass claim. I only hope that Cloudy was smart enough to randomize the Mafia, or at least throw in some non-obvious Mafia role.

[Ruki]

I hate the mass-claim to win thing. Maybe I hate it because I've been scum a lot lately, but I just don't think it's fair.

[Matt]

It's not fair, but why not do it if you can? Mods should incorporate safe claims or mix up the mafia if they don't want their game to turn into a claimfest.

[Gongsun Zan]

Like I said, its up to the game designer to ensure that a mass-claim doesn't kill the game. From what I see of Watchmen, it doesn't seem too bad, but I'll reserve further judgment until the game is over.

[C-MIL]

I wouldn't be surprised at all to see scum push such an agenda if they were given a likely town role.

But yeah, mass-claim games are no fun.

[naiwf]

I know that it's only May 28th, but I think IJS just stole the Worst Play award today from FD and also solidified himself as the Worst Player of 2009 as well. Good lawd.

[Blaze09]

I know that it's only May 28th, but I think IJS just stole the Worst Play award today from FD and also solidified himself as the Worst Player of 2009 as well. Good lawd.

I now know to never give a "green" player a chance at a good role, cause they will probably f it up

[Matt]

IJS totally needs to be given a jester role

[C-MIL]

That was marvelous, well worth the read.

I seriously can't wait for the game summary...

[naiwf]

Certain players should just quietly take the lynch for the town's safety. IJS is one of those players. Instead he just fucked up your whole game. Addition by subtraction is viable sometimes. Any time he's in a game with a vig, the vig should make him the Night 1 target just to minimize the potential damage he can do if you're on the same side, and there's always the chance he could be scum which would just be an added bonus

[GoGo Yubari]

IJS getting lynched wouldn't help us either, though, that's the thing.

[naiwf]

IJS getting lynched wouldn't help us either, though, that's the thing.

That's true now that the cat is out of the bag. But he just threw himself & RW under the bus. RW is going to be pissed, and rightfully so. Bodyguards need to STFU and not get both players killed.

[NobBe Nobbs]

I would push for a mass claim. I only hope that Cloudy was smart enough to randomize the Mafia, or at least throw in some non-obvious Mafia role.

My guess is that the Mafia are Bubastic, Ozymandias and the psychiatrist whose job it is to find Rorschach

[R.W.]

RE: Most Games I'm In Right Now

[Chris the Human]

My brain fucking hurts after reading all 72 pages of Mishaps, Moments, etc mafia.

Jesus.

[R.W.]

Right, that's it, I'm joining the "Taking a break from EWB Mafia" club.

[Ruki]

I've been thinking about it.....

Maybe mafia needs another few month break like last time?

[Matt]

Mysterio2000X

Josh

GoGo

MGW

HTTK

Quasi

First out of those to PM me gets RW's place in the tournament.

[C-MIL]

GoGo and Josh are on hiatus too.

[Matt]

Yeah I know, I just left their names on there because they're on the reserve list and if they do decide they want to play, the offer's still open.