The Mafia Discussion Thread

[Mr Evil Guy]

GoGo's not 'quitting', just took a break IIRC.

[Pesci]

Taking a break is all the rage. We can let guys like pizzamonkey and WOC take over and lead towns into disarray [/unnecessary dig]

EDIT: Awesome, I didn't realise Candor Falls ending meant I had no games left. Sweet, sweet freedom!

Edited May 18, 2009 by Pesci

[Josh]

I think it's quite logical that some people feel this way. Obviously if you're scum you cannot complain, they found out you're scum, done deal. But when you're being attacked for saying something you thought would not get you into trouble and you keep defending yourself but nobody even responds to you via quotes, they lynch you and they see you're town. Yes, I think then it's quite logical you get pissed for a short while. There are two sides to the story usually.

On the contrary, it defies logic. People forget that there is a huge Discrepancy between various players in mafia games and why YOU might realise that you're town-aligned, other people aren't privy to your role PM. People forget this stuff when they're making decisions, when they defend someone, when they accuse someone, basically all the time, someone's forgetting this stuff.

Basically, information is a trap.

Can I replace Sousa in the tournament? I think I deserve a second chance.

No. We will just lynch you first day, anyways.

Give it to GoGo, CWB or Josh, I say.

EDIT: Wait, just remembered GoGo is RIPing from mafia. Give er to CWB/Josh.

I'm on shore leave from mafia as well. CWB takes all the marbles.

And on a serious note, can someone link me to the lounge post wherein Sousa explained what's prompted him to leave? (I'm about to go hunt it down, but thought I'd ask.) It's no secret that I like the dude, and I'm concerned.

[Matt]

"I'm leaving for a while" or something.

[LittleDaniel]

http://www.ewbattleground.com/forum/index....=72986&st=0

[SeanDMan]

I'm tempted to get replaced in the two mafias I am in purely to fit in with the cool kids.

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

Hey Empee still cool! You pay later! LATER!

[Forky]

All these people leaving and I'm looking to make a return to mafia. Not that it's epic or anything, but ya know.

[StevenRichardsRules]

People, when you're replacing players in your mafia game, give me the spot. Seriously, I'm probably reading your mafia anyways.

I keep getting passed over in signup threads too.

[Gongsun Zan]

I'm sad Candor Falls died prematurely. I really wanted to see how that would have played out.

My plan was to kill Pesci, since I was sure he was suspicious of me and trying to lure me out by being super agreeable.

[R.W.]

R.I.P. Logical Thought.

We barely knew ye.

[C-MIL]

Too many name changes. Who was Logical Thought again?

[DMN in the House]

I think its a little late for a eulogy, ARR-DUB.

[R.W.]

:lmao:

[NobBe Nobbs]

I have to say, I find it hilarious the cognitive dissonance some of you have got going, where if you ever get lynched, it's because the town wouldn't listen to logic and not because you did something stupid.

R.I.P. Logical Thought.

We barely knew ye.

It's like MPH could see the future!

[R.W.]

Be - Jumping to the wrong conclusions since May 05

[NobBe Nobbs]

Be - Jumping to the wrong conclusions since May 05

It's what I do

[theburninator77]

I'm thinking about making a mafia game. Question: Is it better to just go ahead and go with it and then get feedback/critique on it, or should I maybe talk to a more experienced mafia member and see if my game is properly balanced and stuff before I register it?

Edited May 19, 2009 by theburninator77

[Matt]

Depends, different people like to do different things. Tell me what your theme is, and if it's something I'm not familiar with, I'll give you a hand if you like.

[C-MIL]

You should probably do both.