The Mafia Discussion Thread

[Pizza]

I'd rather be gay than an outed lie detector in a mafia game.

[naiwf]

Mafia Commandment # 1: Thou shall not provoke Sousa.

[Sousa]

Addendum: Thou shalt not make stupid "GAWD SOUSA ALWAYS ACTS THIS WAY" demands of Sousa when Sousa's last post announced that he wasn't going to act a certain way.

[C-MIL]

Not exactly helping your case though.

[Matt]

To be fair, I didn't make that remark... or it wasn't intended to be read like that, it was intended to be as "all outed mafia dons end up doing it" rather than "sousa always does it".

[Sousa]

Bwahahahaha, glorious.

[SeanDMan]

Change Vote: HttK

For misspelling Vader. Your spelling mistakes are showing up very strongly on my VADAR, which is like a radar except I kick your ass.

Best ability ever.

[DMN in the House]

I think that if I ever have a nightkill, I'm just going to use it on FF. Fuck that guy. Unlynchable Dons should always be over the top, trying to distract the town and getting them to attempt to lynch them as many times as possible. Shit, when I was Chris Hero I came out at the start of the game, and it worked beautifully.

[Mr Evil Guy]

I remember when I first did that, no one else was doing it, now all the cool kids are doing it.

This was like 2 years ago for Alphabet Mafia, I didn't do annoying shit after I was outed on like day 2, but I did stuff like "Change Vote: my mafia partner That should be lynch " when it was one vote away so people would be like "wait a second, let's back up."

I did a bunch of cool shit I bragged about to TEOL. I used to be so cool.

[Gongsun Zan]

I agree about lie detectors. Boo to them. Boo to them, I say.

[Josh]

I agree about lie detectors.

And yes, I may or may not have included one in You Pick.

I also may or may not have included a pant load of other ridiculously over-the-top abilities.

It's You Pick.

[naiwf]

I'm starting to wonder if any of my suggestions were used. I think either # 1 or # 3 probably got in, and I have a feeling I'll find out pretty soon one way or the other. It's a fun game to watch. I think I'm better off as a viewer of the large games.

[Josh]

Well, thank fuck that SOMEONE'S enjoying it.

[NobBe Nobbs]

Oh, I'm enjoying it alright. DMN's gimmick/roleposting is exquisite.

[naiwf]

I think my role would have been better if I had to post as a flaming queen. I probably should have done it on my own, but I didn't want to commit to gimmick posting when I knew I was going to die early.

[Gongsun Zan]

Dear RW,

Am I allowed to run Mafia Cube Mafia, or is it one of those things you get to keep for yourself?

[Guest ToffeeFan2k8]

Isn't that essentially this one - EWB Game Cube Mafia?

[Gongsun Zan]

Well, I did it first.

Three and a half times, actually. Admittedly, the Game Cube hadn't formed by then, so you could argue that it's not the same thing, but by the time I ran the last one Mafia had overrun the Cube anyway so quite a fair share of the roles were Mafia-based by then.

Also, you'd find that my idea of game design is a lot different from RW's. Is it different enough to warrant a remake of his game? I would say so, but I don't want to step on his toes, so if he says no, I'll just drop the idea and let him do it.

Edited April 17, 2009 by Zan and Max

[R.W.]

No, by all means go for it (Y)

[Gongsun Zan]

Huggies~!

Not till after Arkham though.