The Mafia Discussion Thread

[TEOL]

Well duh, both its mods are AWOL.

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

This RoughKut Mafia is terrible. Day one, we lynch a vigilante/investigator rule. And my three-person Mafia has two kills for some reason.

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

So I hear Zan's got another Mafia in the pipeline. In the interest of generating discussion, post your top 5 Mafia players in EWB history (not counting yourself).

Mine would be, in no particular order: Zan, GoGo, oldskool, Josh-oo-wuh, TEOL (who will be heartbroken should he learn who I originally had in that spot until I remembered his existence).

[GoGo Yubari]

Man, I really miss Josh-oo-wuh. He was awesome.

[Slogger]

I would have to be the worst Mafia player in EWB history.

[GoGo Yubari]

I would have to be the worst Mafia player in EWB history.

Oh my god, no. There were at least one or two guys who were just hilariously bad who you could outsmart with your eyes closed (I'm sure that phrase made some sort of sense as long as you don't think about it).

Edited November 22, 2007 by GoGo Yubari

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

Melkon_Firebane remains worst ever in my books. For those of you who don't know his story, him and Rashid are friends in real life. Melkon opens up his role PM for Transformers Mafia in front of Rashid, and surprise surprise, he's not on the side of good. Rather than wait for Rashid to say anything, Melkon offers this information up of his own free will.

[GoGo Yubari]

Melkon_Firebane remains worst ever in my books. For those of you who don't know his story, him and Rashid are friends in real life. Melkon opens up his role PM for Transformers Mafia in front of Rashid, and surprise surprise, he's not on the side of good. Rather than wait for Rashid to say anything, Melkon offers this information up of his own free will.

Oh, yeah, Melkon was horrible.

[Plubby]

If memory serves, I had to modkill them

[Ace]

My top 5, at this point in time and given no particular order beside spot #1 are

1. Burniating Pesci

2. GoGo Yubari

2. Mr Evil Guy

2. TEOL

2. Gongsun Zan

LCS used to be on my list, but lately as you pointed out in GCMafia, he's getting easier to pick as Maf. ANyone who denies the awesomeness that is Pesci a fool. I bow to the mans ability to simply outclass an entire town whenever he was a threat.

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

Yes, but I outclassed Pesci in my very first Mafia, and he's been kinda dormant ever since.

[Ace]

Which Mafia was this?

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

Domed. Just ask him! Or LCS!

[Josh]

!!!

MPH and GoGo miss me! Woo-hoo!

And now, time to dissappoint them both in Zan's upcoming mafia.

[The Mask of Norro]

Essa's a decent mafia player, but oh lawd his break down during that one game...? If we had a mafia hall of fame, that should DEFINITELY get included into it. Good memories, good memories.

[Ace]

Josh, I missed you too. Your on my list of favourite Mafia Runners, but I havent seen you play nearly as much as I have the others.

[Plubby]

Everyone keeps mentioning moments when I get fucked over

[Ruki]

I <3 Momo and TEOL.

Also, Norro and GoGo are awesome too.

[thuganomic]

um...what about me? >_>

Winner of You-Pick-Mafia, carried Sirdavs to a win in Nintendo Mafia? Not to mention my awesome win as mayor in SDM Mafia over Be and my first mafia where I was the awesome Mafia don?

[Ruki]

um...what about me? >_>

Winner of You-Pick-Mafia, carried Sirdavs to a win in Nintendo Mafia? Not to mention my awesome win as mayor in SDM Mafia over Be and my first mafia where I was the awesome Mafia don?

True.

Also, I almost survived until the end of You Pick!