The Mafia Discussion Thread

[Sousa]

I never, ever, ever, ever, ever trust oldskool or C-MIL for some reason. C-MIL because he tends to make a lot of short, terse posts that are hard to read, oldskool primarily because he's been scum in nearly every game I've played with him.

[oldskool]

oldskool can't help the luck of the draw

[Sousa]

Really, excluding current games where I wouldn't ask you to say one way or the other, have you and I ever been in a game where we've both been town?

[Matt]

I don't trust Teej, he's always scum... Always.

[R.W.]

This sort of thinking will only cause you problems. Take each game in it's own right, unless a player has a serious tell.

[HailtotheYo]

... so does anyone else have players they always think are scum unless they're explicitly proven not to be? I'm sort of curious due to recent games I've been in where I've noticed that pattern of mine.

you rang

[Pesci]

MPH, definitely. C-MIL to an extent as well.

[NobBe Nobbs]

StopStop and Josh. Hence why, in CHIKARA Mafia, I used an autolynch on one and a night kill on the other.

And they were both evil as shit.

[FireDoughnut]

I hate that in the games where I actually am town I seem to draw the most suspicion.

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

Me.

[Ruki]

GoGo always ALWAYS thinks I am scum.

[GoGo Yubari]

Actually, I don't. My people in that category are C-MIL and JHS above all else, with Teej to a lesser extent.

[SeanDMan]

Teej has obvious tells.

[-A-]

Josh because he's always far too townie and -Matt- because his logic is frequently dodgy at best.

[Josh]

Note: I AM scum in CF of VM.

[SeanDMan]

Another one who is fairly easy to read is Dukes.

I smelt bullshit on him long before he claimed, but his claim was just obscure enough that it was possible but obscure enough that everyone should have known he was making shit up again.

[Sousa]

Passing this along... apparently you can't put more than 45 pictures in a single post.

I had to cut a whole series of dueling s.

[TEOL]

... but no, seriously, wasn't Von Karma executed?

[Sousa]

... but no, seriously, wasn't Von Karma executed?

He might've been, but let's say for the sake of argument that I retconned that, considering how long it took Dahlia Hawthorne to be executed (the time from Phoenix Wright being a whiny bitch kid in a pink sweater to after Morgan Fey's imprisonment in Justice For All, which would've been a period of at least seven or eight years) and considering that, if it did happen, they were coming back in the second game after all of a year and with much less conclusive evidence going "DING DONG VON KARMA'S DEAD."

Bottom line: probably, but I like him more alive.

[TEOL]

Meh. I just vaguely recall... I think it was Franziska mentioning it in JFA, as one of the reasons why she was so determined to get revenge on Phoenix.