The Mafia Discussion Thread

[-A-]

Was that a mafia-originating one? I didn't even realise that

EDIT: But, yeah, if someone who's been around for a while wants to do something like 'best/worst plays of all time' or 'stupidest town group' then that would probably be interesting.

Edited October 20, 2008 by -A-

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

Stupidest play of all time belongs to Melkon_Firebane. No matter what you say about some of Ruki's meltdowns, Gamemaster, or anyone else, Melkon wins the stupidity award.

And worst town was Super Smash Bros. Right Sousa?

[-A-]

Hmmm, I remember playing with him in something like Stephen King or Armageddon Mafia. What did he do?

[Ruki]

The town was pretty bad in Smash. Also, Melkon, what did he do?

My only really bad meltdown was in PLubby's!

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

Ruki, remember your meltdown in Mafia Mafia?

And Melkon was real-life friends with Rashid, who also played Mafias here. In Plubby's first Transformers Mafia, Melkon checked out his role PM at Rashid's house, they both realized he was scum, and then...Melkon told us all he was scum because he figured he was done as soon as Rashid got online.

Edited October 20, 2008 by Mr. Potato Head

[Sousa]

Smash Bros., Jobber Mafia I, and Zodiac Mafia were the worst three towns I'd ever seen.

[Ruki]

That wasn't so much a meltdown as a fucking stupid thing to do.

...and wow, that would have been entertaining.

[GoGo Yubari]

Yeah, "If you can speak to the dead you should talk to Ace, he's my brother and stuff" isn't a meltdown, but it is somewhere in the top five stupidest things scum players have ever said in EWB mafia (#1 is most certainly "heeheeeheeeheehee __ more to go" by Numbers Guy in Heroes Mafia).

[NobBe Nobbs]

Whoa, whoa. Worst game is Reflecto's abortion of a Mafia, everything else is competing for second-worst.

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

Oh, I was wrong.

Rashid actually outed Melkon, and Melkon didn't bother to mount a defence other than "yup, he's right". And Rashid's performance must have been the catalyst for the "or do anything that goes against the spirit of the game" part of the rules.

And Be threatens to leave the Cube forever if people keep voting for him. In a night phase.

[Ruki]

That Heroes mafia play, that was made me comment, and I wasn't even in the game.

I keep hearing about Reflecto's mafia, what was it called? I think I want to read it

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

WOWmafia or something along those lines. It'll be in the main Cube.

[The Mask of Norro]

WOWmafia or something along those lines. It'll be in the main Cube.

Actually, it was in the Cube Library (Y)

[Sousa]

Wait.

So Reflecto was both running the game AND playing the game?

Because that is like the cheapest bullshit I've ever heard ever.

[GoGo Yubari]

Mythology Mafia:

:lmao:

[-A-]

Wait.

So Reflecto was both running the game AND playing the game?

Because that is like the cheapest bullshit I've ever heard ever.

Also, he made up rules to get people he wanted lynched ASAP despite protests about his conflict of interest. And everyone had immune-to-death powers. Everyone. Mine was:

On two nightkill and two lynch occasions, can steal the ability of either his killer (in night kill) in order to save himself OR can switch places with the first person who voted for him in lynches to save himself.

So, yeah, I was immune from the first 4 deaths and I would have gained two wildcard night-kills to use at my whim. Shame the game was catastrophically broken.

[NobBe Nobbs]

Wait.

So Reflecto was both running the game AND playing the game?

Because that is like the cheapest bullshit I've ever heard ever.

Oh, it gets better.

At one point during the game he blames the other players for not recruiting others to the game and forcing him to join.

I couldn't make this up if I tried.

And in the third fucking post, he votes for someone who would later turn out to be evil for absolutely no reason. It's fucking hysterical in hindsight.

Okay, okay...maybe I deserve the votes. Like I said, the only reason I've been playing through is because none of you would get people to add up the ranks and more people were dropping out than signing up. It's fine, no big deal. Even still, I do have to keep you guys in this. If you people are so dumb that you're willing to vote for your own investigator, someone who's been proven time and again to be town-aligned, WHILE there are two Redemption Crew members who outed themselves, feel free. Go ahead. It's on your head if you do it, though. (I know, dumb to role-claim like that as well...but on the other hand...)

By the power of Greyskull! I am HE-MAN! reflecto sucks shit

Edited October 20, 2008 by Berack Obama

[C-MIL]

I forget my ability but it wasn't even remotely close to being that good.

[-A-]

In the interest of disclosure, I was a townie whose night ability was to turn into a serial killer.

Not too bad. He obviously gave everyone pretty awesome abilities and then cruelly manipulated us towards our deaths.

[The Mask of Norro]

Mythology Mafia:

:lmao:

So does this mean you like the whole "Hydra" thing like Sousa does, or...? >_>