The Mafia Discussion Thread

[Pesci]

Ahahahahahaha. What the fuck is up with that?

[R.W.]

It's the Gatekeeper all over again.

[theburninator77]

It's totally not anything like the gatekeeper.

[R.W.]

Well I await the explanation behind it eagerly.

[Ruki]

.....wow.

[naiwf]

I don't see how one game can have 8/23 of the total players die on the final phase there and only one player survives. How does one player get rid of 8 people and how do I get that role in a future game?

[R.W.]

burny's going to tell us.

[naiwf]

Which game was the Gatekeeper in again? I vaguely remember the shitstorm at the end of that one.

Edited August 3, 2010 by naiwf

[R.W.]

Golden City Renaissaince

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

Golden City Renaissance, hence burny's reference to it half an hour ago.

[DavidMarrio]

What happened in that? This feels like a storytime moment from the old guard

[R.W.]

Basically the town killed all the scum, and the Serial Killer, but included in the game was the retarded Gatekeeper role, where if the Gatekeeper is alive at endgame, everyone else dies and only he wins.

Which is a fine way to reward either side for doing everything they are supposed to do to win the game.

[naiwf]

Norro basically confirmed that all he had to do was survive to end game and everyone else dies. How is that any different than the Gaykeeper?

[Sousa]

That was fucking awesome. I am so glad to have relived Plubby's game all over again. And with a gimmick-posting requirement this time.

[R.W.]

Survivor roles should always SURVIVE with the side that won the game, not slaughter them all despite being vastly outnumbered.

[Your Mom]

That was fucking awesome. I am so glad to have relived Plubby's game all over again. And with a gimmick-posting requirement this time.

Does it help at all that I found the gimmick hilarious?

[The Mask of Norro]

And as I said in the game thread, the role WAS incredibly overpowered, but I was confident that I could win it as a standard SK, which was what I had thought I was for the full game until, well, until I unexpectedly won.

Considering the number of scum in the game though burny, making me an SK who wins when the game reaches endgame was a really dangerous move. By night two I could have won the game and killed nearly twenty people in the endgame update by doing so.

[Ruki]

And as I said in the game thread, the role WAS incredibly overpowered, but I was confident that I could win it as a standard SK, which was what I had thought I was for the full game until, well, until I unexpectedly won.

Considering the number of scum in the game though burny, making me an SK who wins when the game reaches endgame was a really dangerous move. By night two I could have won the game and killed nearly twenty people in the endgame update by doing so.

That would have been AWESOME.

[DMN in the House]

Makes me glad that I put zero effort into the game, it obviously didn't deserve any.

Split, I'll play Alias if you really need another player, but I know nothing of the show, except that I didn't care for it.

[Plubby]

Basically the town killed all the scum, and the Serial Killer, but included in the game was the retarded Gatekeeper role, where if the Gatekeeper is alive at endgame, everyone else dies and only he wins.

Which is a fine way to reward either side for doing everything they are supposed to do to win the game.

*sigh*

I've already admitted responsibility for making an overpowered role. People need to admit that they made a bungle in falling for MEG (of all people) saying "I'm indi, but I'm on your side!" (which should never, ever be allowed to pass unchecked) and then not lynching a non-town player they'd had served to them on a platter. That game was winnable for the town, but they lynched players in the wrong order.