The Mafia Discussion Thread

[Sousa]

I can't get Candor Falls to a place where I'm happy with it, just because I'm doing everything I can to cut "confirmed by the game" roles and it's kind of tricky.

[stokeriño]

Speaking of people tinkering with their games...

Could I ask if someone would discuss mafia game arrangements with me? Being completely green as I am in running games, I want to ask questions about different abilities, get advice on whether my selection of roles has the game unbalanced/overpowered/etc., and generally just get a second opinon on setting up my first mafia game.

This would be for 'Yes, Prime Minister Mafia' (I'd be talking in terms of abstract roles, so you don't need to know the show or anything) - but if you volunteer then you can't sign up for the game whenever it comes round...by Christmas 2010, maybe.

PM me if so.

Edit: Cheers Be.

Edited April 1, 2009 by stokeriño

[Josh]

hello all, new guy here looking to play some mafia.

i've played with some folks here sousa & josh particularly.

how's do i go abouts signing up for a game?

MARK. THE FUCK. OUT.

Yeah, I'm not gonna lie. This guy WILL be in YP2.

[Sousa]

...wait, THAT bill?

Awesomesauce.

[FireDoughnut]

No, DA bill!

[Sousa]

Seriously, this bill is going to bring some class to this joint or my name isn't Stonehenge!... on another board.

[bill_da_bill]

[reminder]come up with a better name[/reminder]

[SeanDMan]

Hi bill da bill. I'm Sean Da Man.

[Guest Mr. Potato Head]

And I'm Pity da Phule.

[Gongsun Zan]

EDIT: Goddamit all these OOC threads confuses me.

Edited April 2, 2009 by Zan and Max

[The Mask of Norro]

So, Web Comic Mafia...

http://leasticoulddo.com/

How fucking awesome is that? LICD is running a crossover arc with some other webcomics, and look who their enemies are.

The arc isn't based off of nor does it likely draw any ideas from WCM, but seriously, how fucking awesome is that?

[Gongsun Zan]

Of all the people you decide to put in WebCom Norro, it looks like you're setting yourself up for the most self-destructs in a game award.

[The Mask of Norro]

No complaints over here, I've found it incredibly entertaining

[Ace]

Mine was less a self destruct and more an overload of all the accusations thrown at me.

I'm defending myself in Every. SIngle. Game. That I'm in. it's ridiculous. I'd understand it if there was an actual basis behind it, but its mainly just 'Your Ace. Your Stupid. Die.'

[Gongsun Zan]

But Ace how can you possibly use 'killing who you suspect is scum' as a defense, when you killed Sousa on Night 1?

EDIT: Well, looks like GoGo beat me to it. Bah.

So anyway, what do you guys do if you're a vig?

Personally, I'd just kill everyone from the bottom up, in terms of post count, but that's just me.

Edited April 2, 2009 by Zan and Max

[Jimmy]

Depends of the size of the game as I'd be much, much more reserved in a small game due to the numbers.

[Pizza]

I would kill people who hurt the town no matter what side they're on and chronic lurkers until I started to get legitimate suspicions. Also, somebody make a vig soon, I've never had a killing role beyond mafia goon.

[GoGo Yubari]

I don't/wouldn't use it unless I had some serious hunches or some obviously scum player proved lynch-resistant.

[NobBe Nobbs]

...was that supposed to be Davan? Holy fuck, we accuse Buckley of copy/pasting the same face over and over but does his expression change at all in those three panels? Urgh.

Points for including the Purple-Shirted Eye Stabber, sure, and if Kiyoshi or the CTS turns up it's clearly an homage, but urgh.

So anyway, what do you guys do if you're a vig?

Kill pizzamonkey, then Josh. The latter because he can wriggle out of just about any lynch not supported by an investigation, and most that are, the former because it would be entertaining.

Edited April 2, 2009 by Mike QuackenBe

[Pesci]

But Ace how can you possibly use 'killing who you suspect is scum' as a defense, when you killed Sousa on Night 1?

EDIT: Well, looks like GoGo beat me to it. Bah.

So anyway, what do you guys do if you're a vig?

Personally, I'd just kill everyone from the bottom up, in terms of post count, but that's just me.

Probably kill MEG.

Anything else would be a bonus.