The pilots I've seen, from best to worst:
1. The Black Donnellys
2. Studio 60
3. Raines
4. The Singles Table
5. Standoff
6. The Class
7. Jericho
8. The Nine
9. Runaway
10. Happy Hour
11. Men In Trees
12. Justice
13. Friday Night Lights
14. Vanished
15. Til Death
And a bit of news, since I don't think it's worthy of its own topic but doesn't fit anywhere else: for everyone who's seen The Singles Table, Pascale Hutton, the doctor, has been replaced in her role by Alicia Silverstone. This better not ruin the show, because the original pilot, led solely by John Cho, was awesome.