Everyone seems to be basing the Manning/Vick debate on this weekends games.
Who did Manning play? The Defending Champions
Who did Vick play? The fucking Rams, an 8-8 team.
Manning would have torn through the Rams as well. Vick, well he's never played the Patriots so how can you say he'd have done any better?
Vick is getting way too much hype again this year and needs to show he can beat the NFC's top team, the Eagles, before you go saying he's better than Manning.
Stop comparing the two based upon records too. The NFC was horrid, where as the AFC was super competitive. If the Colts were in the NFC they'd have gotten a first round bye too, and they'd still be alive in the playoffs.
Manning can't perform against the Patriots, well I'm not forming an opinion on who's better untill I see what Vick can do against them.